What concerns about conformity and democracy does Mill express in the selections from On Liberty? How do YOU feel about them?
Mill feels that the people are becoming meek in that they are doing only what is expected of them. Instead of doing what they want and feel, they are conforming to the ideas and arguments of other people. “If the grounds of an opinion are not conclusive to the person’s own reason, his reason cannot be strengthened, but is likely to be weakened, by his adopted of it” They are not making their own plans, they are not forming their own independence, which is the meaning of having liberty. “But it is the privilege and proper condition of a human being, arrived at the maturity of his facilities, to use and interpret experience in his own way.” This meant that we as humans are educated to allow ourselves to make our own way, our own experiences and to not just melt into the background. “He who lets the world, or his portion of it, choose his plan of life for him has no need of any other facilities than the apelike one of imitation.” For all the education and living in the world, if a person lets himself be controlled his environment, then he’s no more use than an animal.
Showing posts with label John Stuart Mill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label John Stuart Mill. Show all posts
Friday, February 26, 2010
Subjection of Women
In The Subjection of Women, Mill bases his argument against the subjugation of the female to the male on a very interesting foundation: that we don't KNOW women's nature, and that the concepts of womanhood and the gender arrangements we assume are natural are, instead, entirely traditional and habitual, rather than based in nature. Focusing on these parts of his argument, discuss whether and in what ways (if any) the assumptions Mill questions are still true today.
I personally think things have greatly improved since Mill's times. Women got the vote, they can work most any job that men can work, and there's even men staying at home and raising children. However, I feel like the expectation for women to obey their husbands and to be the caregiver and housewife are still underlying. "The general opinion of men is supposed to be, that the natural vocation of a woman is that of a wife and mother." Women of a certain age are expected to get/be married and have children, it's seen as unusual in some circles if you're not. Married life these days is not the equivalent of slavery though, it's a partnership. Wife no long equals housewife.
I personally think things have greatly improved since Mill's times. Women got the vote, they can work most any job that men can work, and there's even men staying at home and raising children. However, I feel like the expectation for women to obey their husbands and to be the caregiver and housewife are still underlying. "The general opinion of men is supposed to be, that the natural vocation of a woman is that of a wife and mother." Women of a certain age are expected to get/be married and have children, it's seen as unusual in some circles if you're not. Married life these days is not the equivalent of slavery though, it's a partnership. Wife no long equals housewife.
Labels:
*2010,
*english lit,
John Stuart Mill,
Subjection of Women
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
